Philadelphia Athletics (1871-1875)

35 Greatest Philadelphia Athletics

  1. Dick McBride p, 1871–1876 42
  2. Cap Anson 1b, 1871–1897 25
  3. Wes Fisler 1b, 1871–1876 18
  4. Ezra Sutton 3b, 1871–1888 15
  5. Mike McGeary 2b, 1871–1882 14
  6. Levi Meyerle 3b, 1871–1884 11
  7. John Clapp c, 1872–1883 11
  8. Davy Force ss, 1871–1886 9
  9. Fergy Malone c, 1871–1884 7
  10. Bill Craver 2b, 1871–1877 6
  11. Ned Cuthbert lf, 1871–1884 5
  12. George Hall lf, 1871–1877 5
  13. George Bechtel rf, 1871–1876 5
  14. Denny Mack 1b, 1871–1883 4
  15. John McMullin lf, 1871–1875 4
  16. John Radcliff ss, 1871–1875 4
  17. Al Reach rf, 1871–1875 4
  18. Dave Eggler cf, 1871–1885 3
  19. Cherokee Fisher p, 1871–1878 2
  20. George Heubel rf, 1871–1876 1
  21. Joe Battin 3b, 1871–1890 1
  22. Fred Treacey lf, 1871–1876 1
  23. Count Gedney lf, 1872–1875 1
  24. Tom Miller c, 1874–1875 1
  25. Count Sensenderfer cf, 1871–1874 0
  26. Dickie Flowers ss, 1871–1872 0
  27. Lon Knight rf, 1875–1885 0
  28. Tom Berry rf, 1871 0
  29. William Coon rf, 1875–1876 0
  30. Henry Gilroy c, 1874–1875 0
  31. Tom Pratt 1b, 1871 0
  32. Nate Berkenstock rf, 1871 0
  33. Adam Rocap rf, 1875 -1
  34. John Richmond ss, 1875–1885 -1
  35. Tim Murnane 1b, 1872–1884 -2

Greatest Philadelphia Athletics by Hall Rating

Dick McBride Photo
  1. Dick McBride
  2. Cap Anson
  3. Wes Fisler
  4. Ezra Sutton
  5. Mike McGeary

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the Philadelphia Athletics (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: John Clapp (11)
  2. 1B: Cap Anson (25)
  3. 2B: Mike McGeary (14)
  4. 3B: Ezra Sutton (15)
  5. SS: Davy Force (9)
  6. LF: Ned Cuthbert (5)
  7. CF: Dave Eggler (3)
  8. RF: George Bechtel (5)
  9. P: Dick McBride (42)

Bench

  1. 1B: Wes Fisler (18)
  2. 3B: Levi Meyerle (11)
  3. C: Fergy Malone (7)
  4. 2B: Bill Craver (6)
  5. LF: George Hall (5)
  6. 1B: Denny Mack (4)
  7. LF: John McMullin (4)

Bullpen

  1. P: Cherokee Fisher (2)