New York Mutuals (1876)

24 Greatest New York Mutuals

  1. Joe Start 1b, 1871–1886 1
  2. Bobby Mathews p, 1871–1887 1
  3. Jimmy Hallinan ss, 1871–1878 1
  4. Nat Hicks c, 1872–1877 0
  5. Jim Holdsworth cf, 1872–1884 0
  6. Robert Maloney cf, 1876–1877 0
  7. Fred Treacey lf, 1871–1876 0
  8. John Hatfield lf, 1871–1876 0
  9. Pete Treacey ss, 1876 0
  10. Davy Force ss, 1871–1886 0
  11. George Seward rf, 1875–1882 0
  12. Terry Larkin p, 1876–1884 0
  13. John Hayes lf, 1876 0
  14. Billy West 2b, 1874–1876 0
  15. George Fair 2b, 1876 0
  16. George Heubel rf, 1871–1876 0
  17. Nealy Phelps rf, 1871–1876 0
  18. Jim Shanley , 1876 0
  19. George Bechtel rf, 1871–1876 0
  20. John McGuinness 1b, 1876–1884 0
  21. Bob Valentine c, 1876 0
  22. Al Nichols 3b, 1875–1877 -1
  23. Eddie Booth rf, 1872–1876 -2
  24. Bill Craver 2b, 1871–1877 -2

Greatest New York Mutuals by Hall Rating

Joe Start Photo
  1. Joe Start
  2. Bobby Mathews
  3. Jimmy Hallinan
  4. Nat Hicks
  5. Jim Holdsworth

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the New York Mutuals (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: Nat Hicks (0)
  2. 1B: Joe Start (1)
  3. 2B: George Fair (0)
  4. 3B: Al Nichols (-1)
  5. SS: Jimmy Hallinan (1)
  6. LF: Fred Treacey (0)
  7. CF: Jim Holdsworth (0)
  8. RF: George Seward (0)
  9. P: Bobby Mathews (1)

Bench

  1. CF: Robert Maloney (0)
  2. LF: John Hatfield (0)
  3. SS: Pete Treacey (0)
  4. SS: Davy Force (0)
  5. LF: John Hayes (0)
  6. 2B: Billy West (0)
  7. RF: George Heubel (0)

Bullpen

  1. P: Terry Larkin (0)