Hall of Stats
About
Articles
Franchises
Positions
MLEs
Upcoming Elections
New York Mutuals
(1871-1875)
Jump to:
ARI
ATL
BAL
BOS
CHC
CHW
CIN
CLE
COL
DET
HOU
KCR
LAA
LAD
MIA
MIL
MIN
NYM
NYY
OAK
PHI
PIT
SDP
SEA
SFG
STL
TBR
TEX
TOR
WSN
All Franchises
36 Greatest New York Mutuals
36
Greatest New York Mutuals
0
Hall of Stats Inductees
0
Hall of Fame Inductees
2
Hall of Merit Inductees
3
Best Pitchers
4
Catchers
1
First Basemen
3
Second Basemen
5
Third Basemen
6
Shortstops
3
Left Fielders
4
Center Fielders
7
Right Fielders
0
Designated Hitters
Bobby Mathews
p, 1871–1887
48
Dave Eggler
cf, 1871–1885
18
Joe Start
1b, 1871–1886
17
Candy Cummings
p, 1872–1877
13
John Hatfield
lf, 1871–1876
11
Nat Hicks
c, 1872–1877
7
Rynie Wolters
p, 1871–1873
7
Dick Higham
rf, 1871–1880
5
Jim Holdsworth
cf, 1872–1884
4
Count Gedney
lf, 1872–1875
4
George Bechtel
rf, 1871–1876
3
Candy Nelson
ss, 1872–1890
3
Jack Burdock
2b, 1872–1891
3
Dickey Pearce
ss, 1871–1877
3
John McMullin
lf, 1871–1875
3
Chick Fulmer
ss, 1871–1884
2
Tom Carey
ss, 1871–1879
2
Jimmy Hallinan
ss, 1871–1878
1
Doug Allison
c, 1871–1883
1
Bob Ferguson
3b, 1871–1884
1
Charlie Smith
3b, 1871
1
Bill Boyd
3b, 1872–1875
1
Charlie Mills
c, 1871–1872
1
Jack Remsen
cf, 1872–1884
0
Billy Geer
ss, 1874–1885
0
Joe Gerhardt
2b, 1873–1891
0
Orator Shafer
rf, 1874–1890
0
Alfred Metcalfe
3b, 1875
0
Frank Fleet
2b, 1871–1875
0
Billy Barnie
c, 1874–1886
0
Nealy Phelps
rf, 1871–1876
0
Steve Bellan
3b, 1871–1873
0
Eddie Booth
rf, 1872–1876
-1
Pat McGee
cf, 1874–1875
-1
Tom Patterson
rf, 1871–1875
-1
Phonney Martin
rf, 1872–1873
-2
Greatest New York Mutuals
by Hall Rating
Bobby Mathews
Dave Eggler
Joe Start
Candy Cummings
John Hatfield
All-Time Team
by Hall Rating with the New York Mutuals
(known issues and limitations)
C
:
Nat Hicks
(7)
1B
:
Joe Start
(17)
2B
:
Jack Burdock
(3)
3B
:
Bob Ferguson
(1)
SS
:
Candy Nelson
(3)
LF
:
John Hatfield
(11)
CF
:
Dave Eggler
(18)
RF
:
Dick Higham
(5)
P
:
Bobby Mathews
(48)
Bench
CF
:
Jim Holdsworth
(4)
LF
:
Count Gedney
(4)
RF
:
George Bechtel
(3)
SS
:
Dickey Pearce
(3)
LF
:
John McMullin
(3)
SS
:
Chick Fulmer
(2)
SS
:
Tom Carey
(2)
Bullpen
P
:
Candy Cummings
(13)
P
:
Rynie Wolters
(7)