New York Mutuals (1871-1875)

36 Greatest New York Mutuals

  1. Bobby Mathews p, 1871–1887 48
  2. Dave Eggler cf, 1871–1885 18
  3. Joe Start 1b, 1871–1886 17
  4. Candy Cummings p, 1872–1877 13
  5. John Hatfield lf, 1871–1876 11
  6. Nat Hicks c, 1872–1877 7
  7. Rynie Wolters p, 1871–1873 7
  8. Dick Higham rf, 1871–1880 5
  9. Jim Holdsworth cf, 1872–1884 4
  10. Count Gedney lf, 1872–1875 4
  11. George Bechtel rf, 1871–1876 3
  12. Candy Nelson ss, 1872–1890 3
  13. Jack Burdock 2b, 1872–1891 3
  14. Dickey Pearce ss, 1871–1877 3
  15. John McMullin lf, 1871–1875 3
  16. Chick Fulmer ss, 1871–1884 2
  17. Tom Carey ss, 1871–1879 2
  18. Jimmy Hallinan ss, 1871–1878 1
  19. Doug Allison c, 1871–1883 1
  20. Bob Ferguson 3b, 1871–1884 1
  21. Charlie Smith 3b, 1871 1
  22. Bill Boyd 3b, 1872–1875 1
  23. Charlie Mills c, 1871–1872 1
  24. Jack Remsen cf, 1872–1884 0
  25. Billy Geer ss, 1874–1885 0
  26. Joe Gerhardt 2b, 1873–1891 0
  27. Orator Shafer rf, 1874–1890 0
  28. Alfred Metcalfe 3b, 1875 0
  29. Frank Fleet 2b, 1871–1875 0
  30. Billy Barnie c, 1874–1886 0
  31. Nealy Phelps rf, 1871–1876 0
  32. Steve Bellan 3b, 1871–1873 0
  33. Eddie Booth rf, 1872–1876 -1
  34. Pat McGee cf, 1874–1875 -1
  35. Tom Patterson rf, 1871–1875 -1
  36. Phonney Martin rf, 1872–1873 -2

Greatest New York Mutuals by Hall Rating

Bobby Mathews Photo
  1. Bobby Mathews
  2. Dave Eggler
  3. Joe Start
  4. Candy Cummings
  5. John Hatfield

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the New York Mutuals (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: Nat Hicks (7)
  2. 1B: Joe Start (17)
  3. 2B: Jack Burdock (3)
  4. 3B: Bob Ferguson (1)
  5. SS: Candy Nelson (3)
  6. LF: John Hatfield (11)
  7. CF: Dave Eggler (18)
  8. RF: Dick Higham (5)
  9. P: Bobby Mathews (48)

Bench

  1. CF: Jim Holdsworth (4)
  2. LF: Count Gedney (4)
  3. RF: George Bechtel (3)
  4. SS: Dickey Pearce (3)
  5. LF: John McMullin (3)
  6. SS: Chick Fulmer (2)
  7. SS: Tom Carey (2)

Bullpen

  1. P: Candy Cummings (13)
  2. P: Rynie Wolters (7)