Columbus Buckeyes (1883-1884)

23 Greatest Columbus Buckeyes

  1. John Richmond ss, 1875–1885 16
  2. Pop Smith 2b, 1880–1891 16
  3. Ed Morris p, 1884–1890 15
  4. Frank Mountain p, 1880–1886 9
  5. Fred Carroll c, 1884–1891 8
  6. Bill Kuehne 3b, 1883–1892 7
  7. Fred Mann cf, 1882–1887 7
  8. Tom Brown cf, 1882–1898 6
  9. Rudy Kemmler c, 1879–1889 5
  10. Jim Field 1b, 1883–1898 4
  11. Sam Childs 1b, 1883 0
  12. Bill Schwartz c, 1883–1884 0
  13. John Valentine p, 1883 0
  14. Frank McIntyre p, 1883 0
  15. Al Bauer p, 1884–1886 0
  16. Tom Sullivan p, 1884–1889 0
  17. Tom Mansell lf, 1879–1884 0
  18. Pete Fries p, 1883–1884 0
  19. Gracie Pierce 2b, 1882–1884 -1
  20. John Cahill rf, 1884–1887 -1
  21. Joe Straub c, 1880–1883 -1
  22. Harry Wheeler lf, 1878–1884 -1
  23. Ed Dundon p, 1883–1884 -4

Greatest Columbus Buckeyes by Hall Rating

  1. John Richmond
  2. Pop Smith
  3. Ed Morris
  4. Frank Mountain
  5. Fred Carroll

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the Columbus Buckeyes (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: Fred Carroll (8)
  2. 1B: Jim Field (4)
  3. 2B: Pop Smith (16)
  4. 3B: Bill Kuehne (7)
  5. SS: John Richmond (16)
  6. LF: Tom Mansell (0)
  7. CF: Fred Mann (7)
  8. RF: John Cahill (-1)
  9. P: Ed Morris (15)

Bench

  1. CF: Tom Brown (6)
  2. C: Rudy Kemmler (5)
  3. 1B: Sam Childs (0)
  4. C: Bill Schwartz (0)
  5. 2B: Gracie Pierce (-1)
  6. C: Joe Straub (-1)
  7. LF: Harry Wheeler (-1)

Bullpen

  1. P: Frank Mountain (9)
  2. P: John Valentine (0)
  3. P: Frank McIntyre (0)
  4. P: Al Bauer (0)
  5. P: Tom Sullivan (0)
  6. P: Pete Fries (0)
  7. P: Ed Dundon (-4)