Altoona Mountain City (1884)

18 Greatest Altoona Mountain City

  1. Germany Smith ss, 1884–1898 2
  2. Pat Carroll c, 1884 1
  3. Charlie Manlove c, 1884 1
  4. Taylor Shafer 2b, 1884–1890 0
  5. Clarence Cross ss, 1884–1887 0
  6. John Grady 1b, 1884 0
  7. George Daisy lf, 1884 0
  8. Harry Koons 3b, 1884 0
  9. James Harris 1b, 1884 -1
  10. Frank Shaffer cf, 1884 -1
  11. Jerry Moore c, 1884–1885 -1
  12. Joe Connors cf, 1884 -1
  13. Charlie Berry 2b, 1884 -1
  14. Charlie Dougherty 2b, 1884 -2
  15. George Noftsker rf, 1884 -2
  16. John Murphy p, 1884 -2
  17. Jim Brown p, 1884–1886 -2
  18. Jack Leary ss, 1880–1884 -2

Greatest Altoona Mountain City by Hall Rating

  1. Germany Smith
  2. Pat Carroll
  3. Charlie Manlove
  4. Taylor Shafer
  5. Clarence Cross

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the Altoona Mountain City (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: Pat Carroll (1)
  2. 1B: John Grady (0)
  3. 2B: Taylor Shafer (0)
  4. 3B: Harry Koons (0)
  5. SS: Germany Smith (2)
  6. LF: George Daisy (0)
  7. CF: Frank Shaffer (-1)
  8. RF: George Noftsker (-2)
  9. P: John Murphy (-2)

Bench

  1. C: Charlie Manlove (1)
  2. SS: Clarence Cross (0)
  3. 1B: James Harris (-1)
  4. C: Jerry Moore (-1)
  5. CF: Joe Connors (-1)
  6. 2B: Charlie Berry (-1)
  7. 2B: Charlie Dougherty (-2)

Bullpen

  1. P: Jim Brown (-2)